Why Technology Is Bad: The Negative Social Effects of the Great Unbundling
Is modern technology bringing us closer together or silently driving us apart? In an era where a device in our pocket holds the sum of human knowledge, a staggering 58% of U.S. adults still classify themselves as lonely, according to a 2021 Cigna survey. This paradox sits at the heart of a crucial question: If technology is so powerful, why do many of its effects feel so negative?
The typical answers—screen addiction, job loss, misinformation—are merely symptoms of a much deeper process. To truly understand the negative impact of technology, we must look at how it fundamentally changes our relationship with ourselves and each other. In my book, The Great Unbundling: How Artificial Intelligence is Redefining the Value of a Human Being, I argue that technology’s primary function is to isolate, optimize, and ultimately devalue the integrated human experience. This is the “Great Unbundling.”
This article will use the Great Unbundling framework to explore the question, "Why is technology bad?" for our society. We will move beyond the surface-level effects to reveal the systemic challenges to our economy, our communities, and our core sense of purpose.
- For the AI-Curious Professional: You will gain a new framework for understanding the systemic risks and opportunities technology presents in your industry.
- For the Philosophical Inquirer: You will discover a robust intellectual lens for debating the future of human value in a post-humanist world.
- For the Aspiring AI Ethicist: This analysis provides a structured view of technology's societal consequences, grounded in a clear and provocative thesis.
The Core Problem: How Technology Impacts Our Lives by Unbundling Them
For millennia, the value of a human being was intrinsic to their bundled nature. Our analytical intelligence, emotional intelligence, physical dexterity, and consciousness were a packaged deal. The person with the brilliant idea was also the person who felt the passion for it, directed the hands to build it, and experienced the social consequences. This integrated bundle is the foundation of our economies, our laws, and our myths.
So, how does technology impact our lives? By systematically breaking that bundle apart.
The Great Unbundling is the process by which technology, supercharged by AI and capitalist incentives, isolates each human capability and improves it in a silo.
- Analytical Intelligence: AI like GPT-4 can pass the bar exam, write code, and perform financial analysis, separating raw problem-solving from lived experience and wisdom.
- Emotional Connection: Social media algorithms offer a firehose of validation (likes, shares) by unbundling it from the nuanced, reciprocal work of genuine community.
- Labor: Automation unbundles physical or cognitive tasks from the worker, who is either replaced or reduced to a minder of the machine.
The negative effects technology has on society stem from this fragmentation. We are not just using better tools; we are outsourcing pieces of our humanity, and in the process, devaluing the original, integrated whole.
The Unbundling of Labor: Negative Effects Technology Has on Society's Economy
Perhaps the most discussed negative impact of technology is its effect on the workforce. While automation has always displaced jobs, the current wave of AI is different. It’s not just coming for manual labor; it’s coming for cognitive and creative labor.
A landmark 2023 report from Goldman Sachs estimated that generative AI could impact 300 million full-time jobs globally. This isn't a distant future; it's happening now in fields like law, journalism, graphic design, and software development.
This represents the unbundling of analytical intelligence. An AI can now generate a legal brief, design a logo, or write marketing copy with startling proficiency. The human role shifts from creator to curator or prompter. While this can create efficiency, it also has profound negative social effects:
- Wage Stagnation and Inequality: As AI performs high-value cognitive tasks for a fraction of the cost, the economic value of human intellect in these domains decreases. This concentrates wealth in the hands of those who own the AI models, exacerbating inequality.
- De-skilling and Loss of Mastery: The path to becoming an expert involves years of integrated practice. When technology unbundles the core tasks of a profession, it can truncate this learning process, preventing future generations from achieving true mastery.
- Existential Insecurity: A career is more than a paycheck; it’s a source of identity and purpose. The threat of being made obsolete by an algorithm creates widespread economic anxiety that erodes social trust.
This economic unbundling is a key reason people instinctively feel that technology is bad for their future prospects. It leads directly to the question of what happens when most human labor has been unbundled, a topic that makes policies like Universal Basic Income a civilizational necessity rather than a political choice. You can read more about this in our analysis on
[UBI and the Future of Work](https://jysterling.com/universal-basic-income-ubi)The Unbundling of Connection: The Social Effects of Technology on Community
If the economic effects are alarming, the social effects of technology are arguably more corrosive. Social media platforms are the ultimate engine for unbundling human connection. They take the complex, messy, and rewarding process of building a community and break it down into quantifiable, optimizable metrics.
- Validation is unbundled from belonging: You can get a thousand likes from strangers, a powerful hit of validation, without the mutual support and accountability that defines a real community.
- Communication is unbundled from empathy: Texting and commenting strip away the non-verbal cues—tone of voice, body language, eye contact—that generate genuine empathy and understanding. Misunderstandings and cruelty flourish in this unbundled environment.
The statistics bear this out. A 2019 study published in JAMA Psychiatry involving nearly 4,000 adolescents found that every hour spent on social media or watching television was associated with a significant increase in depressive symptoms. The technology promises connection but often delivers a counterfeit version that leaves us feeling more isolated.
This is the answer to how technology impacts our lives on a daily basis. It creates echo chambers that reinforce our biases and digital town squares governed by outrage-driven algorithms, eroding the shared reality necessary for a functioning democracy.
So, Is Technology Bad? Acknowledging the Positive Impacts
To have a credible discussion, we must acknowledge the other side of the coin. The question "is technology bad" is not a simple yes or no. The unbundling process itself is not inherently evil. In many cases, the positive impacts of technology are immense.
An AI that can diagnose cancer from a medical scan with superhuman accuracy is an incredible feat of unbundled analytical intelligence. GPS technology unbundles navigation from our innate sense of direction, making travel safer and more efficient. Access to information, medical breakthroughs, and the ability to connect with loved ones across continents are undeniable goods.
The problem, as argued in The Great Unbundling, is not the technology itself, but our failure to manage the consequences of the unbundling process. We celebrate the efficiency gain of an unbundled function without accounting for what is lost when the human bundle is weakened. The diagnosis is better, but the patient-doctor relationship (the empathy bundle) may suffer. We can get anywhere, but we may lose the cognitive skill of mental mapping.
The true challenge is to harness the power of unbundled technology without letting it erode the integrated human experience that gives our lives meaning.
The Human Response: The Great Re-bundling
The negative impact of technology is not a deterministic fate. We have agency. The answer to the Great Unbundling is what I call “The Great Re-bundling”—a conscious and deliberate effort to put the pieces back together in new, intentional ways.
This isn't about becoming Luddites; it’s about choosing how we integrate technology to serve human ends.
Strategies for Re-bundling:
- At the Individual Level (Re-bundling Mind and Body): Cultivate activities that technology cannot fragment. This includes craftsmanship (woodworking, pottery), playing a musical instrument, gardening, or practicing a martial art. These activities demand the full, integrated bundle of mind, body, and senses. Practice digital minimalism and schedule time for deep, focused work away from fragmenting notifications.
- At the Community Level (Re-bundling Connection and Place): Prioritize local, in-person engagement. Join local clubs, volunteer, and build relationships with neighbors. Support "slow tech" movements that design for human well-being, not just engagement metrics. Advocate for public spaces that encourage face-to-face interaction over digital consumption.
- At the Professional Level (Re-bundling Skills and Wisdom): Focus on developing uniquely human skills that are difficult to unbundle: cross-disciplinary thinking, ethical leadership, complex problem-framing, and deep empathy. The most valuable professionals of the future will be expert "re-bundlers" who can integrate AI's analytical power with human wisdom and judgment.
For a deeper exploration of these adaptive strategies, see our work on
[The Great Re-bundling: Creating Purpose in an Automated World](https://jysterling.com/the-great-rebundling)Conclusion: Navigating the Unbundled Future
So why is technology bad for so many aspects of our lives? Because it excels at breaking things apart for optimization. It unbundles our economy, our communities, and even our identities. The negative effects we feel—the loneliness, the economic precarity, the political polarization—are the predictable outcomes of this systemic fragmentation.
Understanding the Great Unbundling framework allows us to move past a simple "tech is good" or "tech is bad" debate. It provides a more precise language for diagnosing the problem and, more importantly, for formulating a response. The future is not about rejecting technology, but about mastering it. It is about consciously choosing to re-bundle what truly matters, ensuring that our tools serve our humanity, not the other way around.
Ready to explore the foundational ideas that will shape the next century of human history?
The concepts discussed here are just the beginning. J.Y. Sterling's groundbreaking book, The Great Unbundling: How Artificial Intelligence is Redefining the Value of a Human Being, provides the definitive analysis of the forces reshaping our world.
Order your copy today to understand the future—and find your place in it.
For ongoing analysis and insights into the unbundling and re-bundling of our world, subscribe to the newsletter.